• 0 Posts
  • 714 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle
  • There is intelligence though, just not most of the pieces we associate with human like intelligence.

    As a precursor: a simple air conditioner has enough capability to fit most criteria. A basic history and a clock makes is fit a lot more.
    I’m not arguing that LLM are more than they are, rather that the floor is lower than most people think.

    The air conditioner can measure the value of a probe, compare it to a set point, and control a compressor with the result. Give it a basic memory and a clock and it can start making changes before the difference grows. A little more and we can make it improve the quality of that correction over time.
    This is a smart system. It acts intelligently. It has no sapience, reasoning, or any qualities we would associate with a smart creature.

    Intelligence in the context of AI purely means that the system handles tasks previously relegated to intelligent beings, not that the system is itself a being of any sort.
    Things like spell check are early AI. Measuring a set of values, comparing to a table of knowns and picking a weighted blend is another, like you find in rice cookers and washing machines.
    You don’t have to think as hard because it’s taking care of it for you.

    The LLM is predicting the next symbol in a sequence. It’s able to feed that back into itself to produce longer sequences, and can use that sequence to save portions of the sequence to propagate to later inputs to better adapt the next sequence of generated content.
    It’s not reasoning, or feeling, or even thinking. But none of those are required for a system to be intelligent.



  • Not always. It’s better to say that “military grade” means “very specific standards”.
    That also happens to translate to cheap pretty often, but that’s because someone in 1943 wrote the specification for The Standard Tube Sock and ordered 7,500,000,000 pairs to be delivered over the next century. Since it’s precisely specified you know exactly how much you can skimp.
    Add that to the trillion pages of compatability requirements and you’re basically never updating anything.
    Like how switching lightbulb brands at a nuclear power plant is hard because you need documentation demonstrating that the plastic in the led won’t become a hazard in a radioactive incident.


  • 1800s are pretty different from today.
    Cuba never had a self sufficient military. Most of their heavy equipment came from the soviets and hasn’t been refreshed.

    The island is within helicopter range of multiple US airbases. There’s a well positioned military base already in place on the island.

    Holding a jungle with unwilling people fighting you is never going to be easy, but there’s a lot of differences between what Spain was against and what the US would be against.

    The biggest issue would be that Cuba could plausibly actually land an attack on the US. It would be basically a coin toss on if that made people furious at Cuba or the administration.


  • So the dead people who ran the government 100 years ago used nukes, so you want to burn their great great grandchildren alive.

    How do you feel about Belgium? I assume you want them all flayed alive?

    Historical inequity is distinct from retribution. We have a responsibility to help people overcome hurdles born from historical circumstances, and in general.
    That doesn’t mean we’re culpable for the acts of those who came before.
    Guilt is not heritable.

    If it is, then America is pretty low on the list of countries deserving punishment. Hell, the classic European powers had occupations of countries that lasted longer than the US has existed.













  • Your statement ignores the meaning of AI or the decades of work that have gone into the field.

    They’re not sentient. They’re not sapient. They’re not conscious, nor do they have feelings, volition, desire, or anything that can be described as an internal life. They can’t even think in they sense that anyone means by it.

    None of those things are intelligence though.

    An LLM posesses the ability to respond to external stimuli in a way that is meaningful. They also have the ability to learn, which is the act of a system transforming information or stimuli in a way that is applied to later stimuli.

    My air conditioner learns and is intelligent. It measures the environment, takes actions based on that stimulus, and when I make adjustments it records when I like different settings and applies that to the temperatures it’s recorded in the past to adjust early. An LLM may be more sophisticated than my air conditioner but it’s in the same category.

    The mistake is thinking that AI in the real world is what AI is on TV.